Bobby Brown’s Replacement In New Edition

Bobby Brown’s replacement in New Edition was Johnny Gill. Bobby Brown was kicked out/voted out/left out of the group and they decided to replace him.

Bobby Brown's Replacement In New Edition - Johnny Gill - Urban Music 2000
Urban Music 2000 – New Edition – Ronnie DeVoe, Ralph Tresvant, Johnny Gill, Ricky Bell, Mike Bivens

Initially they tried continuing as a 4 member group but decided the stage presence looked better with 5 people. I agreed. The spacing and dance patterns had a better visual appeal when watching them perform as a 5-unit group.

Bobby Brown's Replacement In New Edition - Urban Music 2000 - Johnny Gill
Urban Music 2000 New Edition – Mike Bivens, Ralph Tresvant, Ricky Bell, Johnny Gill, Ronnie DeVoe

If Johnny Gill wasn’t the chosen replacement for Bobby Brown, who would’ve been a good choice? I was watching a live performance of “Can You Stand the Rain”, and this question came to my mind. Johnny Gill “matured” the sound of New Edition by a mile and garnered a larger audience for New Edition. But, did their sound need to be changed? New Edition was known for their high youthful sounding voices. This was a big part of their appeal, in my opinion. It was reminiscent of many younger groups preceding them including The Jackson 5, The Teenagers, and The Imperials. They recorded 4 albums with their original sound before Johnny Gill came on board.

Bobby Brown's Replacement In New Edition - Urban Music 2000
Urban Music 2000 New Edition – Ronald DeVoe, Michael Bivens, Bobby Brown, Ralph Tresvant, Ricardo Bell

New Edition was originally comprised of 5 members. From left to right:

  • Ronald DeVoe (Ronnie)
  • Michael Bivens (Mike)
  • Bobby Brown (Bobby)
  • Ralph Tresvant (Ralph)
  • Ricardo Bell (Ricky)

They could’ve kept their original sound with these male artists:

Bobby Brown’s New Edition replacement alternatives:

This short list was hard to compile because I had to find established artists of the late 80s in the age of range of the New Edition members at that time. I found a good amount of people, but they were just slightly older than the members at that time. O’Bryan, El Debarge, D Train, Eugene Wilde, Lillo Thomas. The other issue was finding someone who wasn’t already a member of another group at that time. The replacement also had to possess natural dancing abilities.

Bernard Wright

Chico DeBarge

Tony Terry

Chuckii Booker

One thought on “Bobby Brown’s Replacement In New Edition

Comment